Africa Horn Now

"We don't take sides; we help you see more sides."

Africa Horn Now
  • Home
  • AHN News
  • Seen/Heard
  • LIFE iN BaW
  • Insight
  • All articles
  • ትግርኛ/ አማርኛ
  • Svenska
  • CONTACT

State of democracy in Africa: changing leaders doesn’t change politics

August 17, 2020 By AHN

Nic Cheeseman |August 11, 2020 | The Conversation

For the last few years the African political landscape has been dominated by high profile changes of leaders and governments. In Angola (2017), Ethiopia (2018), South Africa (2018), Sudan (2019) and Zimbabwe (2018), leadership change promised to bring about not only a new man at the top, but also a new political and economic direction.

But do changes of leaders and governments generate more democratic and responsive governments? The Bertelsmann Transformation Index Africa Report 2020 (BTI), A Changing of the Guards or A Change of Systems?, suggests that we should be cautious about the prospects for rapid political improvements.

Reviewing developments in 44 countries from 2017 to the start of 2019, the report finds that leadership change results in an initial wave of optimism. But ongoing political challenges and constraints mean that it is often a case of “the more things change the more they stay the same”.

Political change occurs gradually in the vast majority of African countries.

More continuity than change

From 2015 to 2019, the general pattern has been for the continent’s more authoritarian states – such as Djibouti, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea and Rwanda – to make little progress towards democracy. In some cases countries became incrementally more repressive.

At the same time, many of the continent’s more democratic states – including Botswana, Ghana, Mauritius, Senegal and South Africa – have remained “consolidating” or “defective” democracies. Very few of these dropped out of these categories to become “authoritarian” regimes.

A number of countries have seen more significant changes. But in most cases this did not fundamentally change the character of the political system. For example, Cameroon, Chad, Kenya and Tanzania moved further away from lasting political and economic transformation. Meanwhile Angola, Ethiopia, Sierra Leone and Zimbabwe initially made progress towards it, but these gains were limited – and only lasted for a short period in Ethiopia and Zimbabwe.

As this brief summary suggests, at a continental level the trajectories of different states have by and large cancelled each other out. Positive trends in some cases were wiped out by negative trends in others.

Sub-Saharan Africa as a whole has thus seen no significant changes to the overall level of democracy, economic management and governance. For example, the index shows that between 2018 and 2020, the overall level of democracy declined by just 0.09, a small shift on a 1-10 scale. This suggests continuity not change.

Leadership changes often disappoint

In almost all cases, positive trends were recorded in countries where leadership change generated hope for political renewal and economic reform. This includes Angola, after President José Eduardo dos Santos stepped down in 2017, and Ethiopia, following the rise to power of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed. It also includes Zimbabwe, where the transfer of power from Robert Mugabe to Emmerson Mnangagwa was accompanied by promises that the Zanu-PF government would show greater respect for democratic norms and values in future.

Sierra Leone also recorded a significant improvement in performance following the victory of opposition candidate Julius Maada Bio in the presidential election of 2018. Nigeria has continued to make modest but significant gains in economic management since Muhammadu Buhari replaced Goodluck Jonathan as president in 2015.

The significance of leadership change in all of these processes is an important reminder of the extent to which power has been personalised. But it is important to note that events since the end of the period under review in 2019 have cast doubt on the significance of these transitions.

Most notably, continued and in some cases increasing human rights abuses in countries such as Ethiopia, Nigeria, Tanzania and Zimbabwe suggest that we have seen “a changing of the guards” but not a change of political systems.

Nowhere is this more true than Zimbabwe, where the last few weeks have witnessed a brutal government crackdown. Not only have journalists been arrested on flimsy charges, but the rule of law has been manipulated to keep them in jail. Following this sustained attack on democracy, it is now clear that the Mnangagwa government is no more committed to human rights and civil liberties than its predecessor was.

There is no one ‘Africa’

So what does the future hold? I often get asked what direction Africa is heading in. My answer is always the same: where democracy is concerned, there is no one “Africa”. The Bertelsmann Transformation Index report shows how true this is.

In addition to the well-known differences between leading lights like Botswana and entrenched laggards like Rwanda, there is also a profound regional variation that is less well recognised and understood.

From relatively similar starting points in the early 1990s, there has been a sharp divergence between West and Southern Africa – which have remained comparatively more open and democratic – and Central and Eastern Africa, which remained more closed and authoritarian. There is also some evidence that the average quality of democracy continued to decline in Eastern and Central Africa in the past few years. Because it continues to increase in West Africa, we have seen greater divergence between the two sets of regions.

Figure 1. Average Democracy scores for African regions, BTI 2006-2020*

These variations reflect the historical process through which governments came to power, the kinds of states over which they govern, and the disposition and influence of regional organisations. In particular, East Africa features a number of countries ruled by former rebel armies (Burundi, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Rwanda, Uganda). Here political control is underpinned by coercion and a longstanding suspicion of opposition.

This is also a challenge in some Central African states. Here the added complication of long-running conflicts and political instability (Central African Republic, Chad, Democratic Republic of Congo) has undermined government performance in many ways.

A number of former military leaders have also governed West African states, including Ghana, Nigeria and Togo. But the proportion has been lower and some countries, such as Senegal, have a long tradition of plural politics and civilian leadership. In a similar vein, Southern Africa features a number of liberation movements. But in a number of cases these developed out of broad-based movements that valued political participation and civil liberties. Partly as a result, former military or rebel leaders have had a less damaging impact on the prospects for democracy in Southern and West Africa.

It is important not to exaggerate these regional differences. There is great variation within them as well as between them. But, this caveat notwithstanding, we should not expect to see any convergence around a common African democratic experience in the next few years. If anything, the gap between the continent’s most democratic and authoritarian regions is likely to become even wider.

Nic Cheeseman is Professor of Democracy, University of Birmingham.

Related reading: Is Africa going backwards on democracy?

Uganda – How Museveni plans to “win” the 2021 elections

Filed Under: UPFRONT


Do you have questions?  Feel free to contact us!

 [ssba]

WELCOME!

Hummingbirdlogo140906_edited-1Africa Horn Now (AHN) is an independent online publication focused on raising major news and views affecting the lives and times of people living in the African Horn. AHN (https://ahn.nu) goes farther and digs deeper to bring you stories that matter. AHN offers reads that inform, inspire and empower! Sweden is home of https://africahornnow.com.

QUICK MEDIA LINKS (TV/RADIO)

Radio Sweden

EriTv

ድምፂ ረድዮ ኣሜሪካ (VOA Tigrigna)

Radio Erena

ፕሮግራም ሬድዮ መድረኽ (Radio EriMedrek)

ዶይቸ ቬለ (DW Amharic)

EBC TV (Ethiopia)

VOA Afaan Oromoo

VOA/Amharic የአሜሪካ ድምፅ

ESAT Radio

Citizen TV  (Kenya)

NTV (Uganda)

South Sudan TV

Universal Somali TV

SABC (South Africa)

Russia Today

Aljazeera (English)

Aljazeera (الجزيرة نت)

Radio France International (RFI)

France 24

NPR

PBS

BBC

CNN

CCTV (China)

AHN-Weather

 

Archives

  • May 2021
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • June 2019
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • November 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • May 2014
  • March 2014

Tags

aAfrican politics Africa ANC Angola Authoritarian constitutions Authoritarianism not key to China’s economic success authoritarian regimes Authoritarian State authoritarian states Burundi Competitive authoritarian COMPETITIVE AUTHORITARIANISM Covid-19 democratic government and society Earthquake economy Egypt elections Eritrea Ethiopia FEEDING THE DRAGON Greece hybrid regime type India Kenya Mugabe Nepal new sort of authoritarian rule Nigeria North Korea opposition Pierre Nkurumziza Postcolonial Africa Postcolonial African regimes Presidential Election 2015 Quake repressing civil society and silencing dissent Rwanda South Africa Types of Authoritarian regimes Uhuru US US Trip women's league Zimbabwe

Recent Posts

  • ካብ ውሽጢ ቤት ማእሰርታት ኤርትራ

    May 6, 2021
  • Sudan announces failure of GERD negotiations, returns file to African Union

    November 6, 2020
  • Satellite data provides fresh insights into the amount of water in the Nile basin

    November 6, 2020
  • A New Administration Won’t Heal American Democracy

    November 6, 2020
  • Ethiopia blasts Trump remark that Egypt will ‘blow up’ dam

    October 24, 2020
[ssba]

Contact

[contact-form to=’editor@africahornnow.com’ subject=’Contact from africahornnow contact page’][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]

Log In

Copyright © 2022 Africa Horn Now · WordPress · Log in